Thankfully this time I don't have anyone I owe an apology to. It really does surprise me just how bad of a year Disney had in 2022, not all of their cinematic releases were bad, but many had some sort of baggage attached to them, Turning Red and Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers being the most notable examples, and most of the movies just had terrible advertising, looking at you Bob's Burger's Movie and Strange World. I will admit, 2023 and 2024 have kind of forced me to re-evaluate how I saw 2022's animated feature line-up, and since their has been some ramblings about Lightyear again, I figured, even though I would like to wait five years before reviewing a movie I did a First Impressions blog on, that now would be a good opportunity to give Lightyear another look, and see if my initial impressions hold up.
Lightyear is the origin movie of the beloved Pixar character, Buzz Lightyear, and follows he and his crew as they become stranded on an alien planet. Thanks to some time dilation brought on by FTL Travel, Buzz finds himself years ahead in the future, and his crew decided to stay on the planet instead of leaving. After one more test for hyperspace travel, Buzz finds himself further into the future and leading a small junior troop of trainees to take down the invading robot army from Zurg. So... itty bitty thing, some people may view this plot as a bit complicated, and to be fair I may have put more description into it than necessary, but I kind of followed it decently fine. I grew up with science-fiction, Star Wars was the big one, but I also knew Red Dwarf, Stargate SG-1, and knew of Star Trek, though I wouldn't get into it until at least Young Adulthood. I don't find much of this all that confusing, if anything, it's kind of plain and standard for science-fiction.
I think some people might have expected, or even wanted, this movie to evoke the vibes of 90s Science-Fiction movies, to which I have to reply... why? Like what was big in sci-fi in 1995? Congo, Johnny Mnemonic, Judge Dredd, Species, Tank Girl, Waterworld, did you really want Lightyear to be reminiscent of those movies? Like 1990s Sci-Fi was actually pretty lousy when you look at what was actually released, yes there was lots of good stuff, but your Jurassic Park's and Freaked's were few and far between. Then again, it isn't also like they were really trying to evoke the feelings on 90s Sci-Fi, a lot of the writing and cinematography is very much 2010s sci-fi. Whether or not this is a bad thing I think is perfectly fine to argue about, personally, I can see both sides of the argument, this is meant to be a movie from the 1990s, the opening text straight up says this is the movie that Andy saw in the theatres, so a more 90s style would have given this movie more of an identity. However, once again, science-fiction movies in the 1990s sucked, at least sucks by today's standards, so I honestly don't think it would have made the movie that much better.
What would have made the movie better is a change in plot, because I really liked the relationship Buzz had with Commander Hawthorne at the start of the movie. I could tell they were friends for a long time and it did hurt Buzz to see how much of his friend's life he was missing out on. That montage in the first third of the movie, I would have loved to see that get fleshed out into the entire movie. Not that the other characters are bad, but they are kind of standard. You have your cowardly character, your gruff character that's just done with everything, your character that has high aspirations and needs to learn to overcome those few things that hold them back. Of course, you also have your twist villain, I'm not gonna bother hiding any spoilers here because, most people already know this, but Zurg is actually a future Buzz Lightyear. I think this irritates a lot of people because it means we have to put the relationship between Zurg and Buzz in previous iterations (most notably the Star Command TV Show) into a different light. I don't really mind it, but then again I never watched Buzz Lightyear of Star Command. So, on the one hand it's not a terrible twist villain, but on the other hand, there had to have been a better option here, right?
Speaking of better options, the animation in this movie is lacking. Not the animation itself, it's pretty solid, it's Pixar standard, no I'm talking more about the colour palette. It is largely brown and yellow, and it's just no pleasant to look at. Thankfully, when the palette does change, like the bright colours of hyperspace or the blues of the night, it doesn't look too bad. I feel like everything about this movie is just a one to three steps short of everyone's expectations, and I get it, after Soul and Luca we were kind of expecting something great, right? Well... I wasn't, I don't want to come off as saying "I knew better" because frankly, I didn't watch Soul or Luca, so obviously I didn't, but I did expect a decently entertaining movie to welcome one of the best animation studios back onto the big screen. This is a very, temper your expectations kind of movie.
I think therein lies the crux of why I don't hate Lightyear, if you're anticipating a half-way decent action/sci-fi flick, you're gonna find it here. I think the biggest problem is that people expect a lot of Pixar, and also have a lot of emotional ties to the Toy Story franchise. It really doesn't help that as far as canon is concerned, we're actually getting the Buzz Lightyear story in reverse, like we got the Star Command series first, then this movie, plus four Toy Story movies, so we can't really separate Toy Story or Buzz Lightyear of Star Command from this movie. I think if this wasn't tied to Toy Story, and was just a dumb sci-fi popcorn flick, people would have reacted much better, so I really don't know what to suggest here. Overall, I don't think it's a bad movie, trust me, I've seen much worse, but it definitely isn't one of Pixar's best. I'll go Slight Recommendation because I think, in the right mindset you can enjoy this movie, but even then, there is probably a better option for you out there.
